Thank you for your participation in the consultation on the development of the Bonsucro Production Standard for Smallholder Farmers (“Smallholder Standard”) and Bonsucro Calculator for Smallholder Farmers. The following is a draft version of the standard for public consultation. The Smallholder Standard follows the Principles and Criteria published in the Bonsucro Production Standard as much as possible, initially launched in 2011. The indicators and threshold requirements for performance have been amended to improve accessibility for the smallholder context. This is a very important process for standards revision to ensure stakeholder engagement and success of the document’s uptake. We value your feedback!
The first consultation period is open from 15th December to 15th February.
It is important to use both the Standard and Calculator for reference to complete these questions.
Suitability Criteria and Review Conclusions on the Design of the Smallholder Standard and Calculator
- Standard is not clear in the requirements for smallholder farmers- it is a challenge to transfer them to individual fields: Changes made captured from feedback from using the standard, introduction of farm level input data in addition to the group
- Inability to improve practices in the field and/or how to do so: Acknowledgement that this might remain as an issue after launch
- Inability to collect data: Reduced from 111 data points to 25 for individual farm, 40 for group
- Inability to aggregate data to one single calculator once collected: Introduce sampling for farm data collection at the group level (no requirement to aggregate farm information)
- Lack of indicators on governance (as seen in peer standards on cooperative clear management structure): Key performance indicators for the group within the Smallholder Calculator and introduction of Principle 7: Organisation of Farmers
- Footprint indicators are not meaningful for smallholder farmers: Removed data collection for footprint indicators, but maintained key contributors to inform calculations at the regional/global scale
A summary of the consultation notes will be shared on the website once the consultation is closed, and individual comments (without identifying information) will be shared with the Smallholder Steering Committee in some cases for decision making on inclusion.